Proposed Florida Laws Strip Medical Care Decisions Away From Doctors When Personal Injury Claims Are Considered

UPDATE - HB379 Has Been Defeated In The Florida Legislature

You could be forgiven for thinking messing around with healthcare coverage rules was the sole domain of democrats these days, but the new laws which will deeply interfere with the choices a doctor will make and options available for the seriously injured have sprung from the minds of two republican lawmakers.

The bills which include, House Bill 379 from Rep. Hood, and Senate Bill 1128 From Senator Richter, aim to reduce care given for accident injuries by placing medical decisions in the hands of juries – not doctors.

That's right, the proposed laws would place the decision on what medical procedures performed on the patient should be awarded compensation with a jury- regardless of what the doctor has determined what the patient will need.

As an experienced trial lawyer I have presented cases to many juries, and while they are comprised of wonderful Florida citizens doing their part for our society, I am sure they are not even remotely qualified to describe what medical care a doctor should or should not be providing.

The proposed bills would also have doctors at serious odds with their patients and clog the courts with further civil law suits.

Picture this... A man has been severely injured during a motorcycle accident where another driver has ran a red light causing the accident.

The doctors and staff perform heroically, with life saving and reconstructive surgery to bring their patient some measure of recovery and quality of life after the crash.

The patient is then in need of many months if not years of special therapy to be able to fully recover from the severity of the injuries, and further testing for possible lasting brain injury.

The doctor has provided all of this care without thinking, not just because it's the moral thing to do, but also because he assumes at some point he and his staff of highly trained professionals will be compensated for their life-saving work.

Now the injured man has been the recipient of hundreds of thousands of dollars in medical treatment, not because he wanted it, but because a careless driver smashed into him, and is forced to seek fair compensation to pay for the damages he received.

During the trial, the new laws would have the jury decide what medical care the doctors and medical staff have already provided should be compensated for, and what therapies should be paid for in the future.

If the jury fails to award compensation for the medical treatment already provided and received by the accident victim, the doctor will be out of luck.

Of course doctors, hospitals and other medical specialist cannot simply walk away when they have provided tens of thousands of dollars or more in medical care and need to pay their own staff, so the doctor or hospital may be forced to sue the patient to recover the amount owed!

The huge amount of fiscal uncertainty these new bills will create has not been lost on Florida doctors.

Recently I joined with several doctors and other attorneys to voice our concerns with these bills directly in Tallahassee. Unfortunately HB379 has cleared the committee and will be moving toward a vote.

Should these misguided bills be made into law they will have a chilling effect on doctors and hospitals response to accident injuries. The new laws will open up a host of law suits as medical care providers are forced to pursue collections against their patients causing undo economic harm to not just the injured victim but the medical provider as well. In reality it's not very likely that someone who has been disabled by a serious accident will be able to personally work off huge medical debts no matter what a court decides.

With so much potential harm to the Florida public and medical providers you have to wonder who stands to gain from such laws.

It's tough to see any beneficiary from these proposed rules other than the already ridiculously profitable insurance industry, however there are plenty of people who will be harmed. The list includes accident victims, the medical industry, the legal system and the citizens of Florida.

If you oppose the latest attempt by the insurance industry to increase their profits at the expense of policy holders and medical professionals, contact your state lawmakers and help stop HB 379 and SB 1128 from becoming law.

David Goldman

Attorney David Goldman has a strong belief that everyone should be treated fairly and those with the means should do what they can to bring justice in all areas of our society. That belief has lead him to help Florida's injured from being taken advantage of by corporations and insurance companies. Since 1989 David Goldman has been fighting for the rights of Floridians both as an attorney and by personally supporting our community.



Client Testimonials

Attorney David Goldman has been exceptional in the process of helping me through the case. He has always been easy to reach, whether by phone or email, and has thorough knowledge and explains clearly in depth so you feel safe and confident in your lawyer

I used Michael Babboni and his paralegal, Nicole Moore for a legal matter. They went above and beyond my expectations. During the entire process there was constant communication with both Michael and Nicole. They were extremely organized and on top of my case, which I am very grateful for. Michael truly had my best interests at heart and he was very genuine. I plan on referring Michael to all family and friends and will continue to use him in the future.

I dealt most with Mr. Fernandez. I didn’t know a lot about this process. He took the time to speak with me individually, in person, to explain everything. It was very helpful to actually know and understand the process and what to expect. He closed my case quickly, which was nice that it was not prolonged! I appreciated his hard work and getting me what I felt I deserved after my car accident. I highly recommend him to anyone who needs an honest and reliable lawyer to assist you with your case!

I hired Mr. Walsh after an automobile accident this past March. He and his entire staff were extremely professional. They kept me informed every step of the way and settled my case in a timely manner. Thank you so much for your help.


Law Offices Near You

Sarasota Office

Sarasota Personal Injury Law Office


2822 University Parkway Sarasota Florida 34243

Bradenton Office



1215 Manatee Ave West Bradenton Florida 34205

St. Petersburg Office

St. Petersburg


6446 Central Avenue St. Petersburg Florida 33707

Lakewood Ranch Office



9040 Town Center Pkwy, Lakewood Ranch Florida 34202

Venice Office



3986 S. Tamiami Trail Venice Florida 34293

Englewood Office



2960 S. McCall Rd Englewood Florida 34224

Punta Gorda Office

Punta Gorda


122 Nesbit St, Suite 113, Punta Gorda Florida 33950

Port Charlotte Office

Port Charlotte


3986 Tamiami Trail Port Charlotte Florida 33952

Arcadia Office



10 South DeSoto Avenue Arcadia Florida 34266

Fort Myers Office

Fort Myers


8359 Beacon Blvd Fort Myers Florida 33907

Lakeland Office



5137 S. Lakeland Dr. Lakeland Florida 33813

Get personal attention from a lawyer with decades of experience.